

So if you're looking to create a specific map whose layout remains the same, go with galaxy forge, but if you're looking to play a user defined map thats different every time you play it, go with the in-game designer. The in-game designer lacks much of the customizability that galaxy forge offers, but where it is lacking, it makes up for in ease of distribution and random generation. Its a strength and a weakness at the same time.

2) While you can set planets to be randomly generated in galaxy forge, their positions and phase lanes are absolute, which while you may not consider it shortcoming, consider that most MP games are played on randomly generated maps. 1) Galaxy forge maps are difficult to distribute to other players because the multiplayer engines (LAN/ICO) have no map downloading feature. Galaxy forge is certainly a stronger map designer, but it has a two shortcomings that the in-game designer doesn't. Galaxy Forge has cast a huge shadow on the sins in-game map designer, which many have ignored because its a bit difficult to work with, and takes time to figure out.
